When the order is lost
Misplaced Priorities
The fiqh of priorities says what comes first. A misplaced priority is a good deed in the wrong place: a refinement before a necessity, the voluntary before the obligatory, the passing before the lasting, the seen before the greater harm.
Below are the commonest ways the Ummah's effort goes to the wrong place first, each with the principle it breaks, what it costs and what comes first instead.
Misplaced priorities
Misplaced priorities
Ten ways the order is lost. Pick one to see the principle it breaks, what it costs, what comes first instead and its source.
- 01
Another umrah while the neighbour starves
A voluntary act put before a duty that no one is carrying. The repeated umrah, the third ḥajj, the private night of worship are good, but not while a Muslim nearby has no food and the money that would feed him goes on travel.Principle brokenThe obligation before the voluntary; a deed whose benefit reaches others before one that stays with the doer.What it costsA life or a family kept from ruin, set against a reward that is voluntary and can be had another year.Put first insteadZakat paid in full and on time, then the hungry and the besieged nearest to you, then the voluntary journey.“He is not a believer whose stomach is filled while his neighbour goes hungry.”al-Bukhārī, al-Adab al-Mufrad 112“Do you make giving water to pilgrims and tending the Sacred Mosque equal to one who believes in Allah and the Last Day and strives in His cause? They are not equal before Allah.”Qur'an 9:19“He set out for ḥajj, met a family eating carrion from hunger, gave them his provision and went home, saying this was better than his ḥajj that year.”ʿAbdullāh ibn al-Mubārak (reported)1 of 10
01
Another umrah while the neighbour starves
A voluntary act put before a duty that no one is carrying. The repeated umrah, the third ḥajj, the private night of worship are good, but not while a Muslim nearby has no food and the money that would feed him goes on travel.
Principle brokenThe obligation before the voluntary; a deed whose benefit reaches others before one that stays with the doer.
What it costsA life or a family kept from ruin, set against a reward that is voluntary and can be had another year.
Put first insteadZakat paid in full and on time, then the hungry and the besieged nearest to you, then the voluntary journey.
“He is not a believer whose stomach is filled while his neighbour goes hungry.”
al-Bukhārī, al-Adab al-Mufrad 112
“Do you make giving water to pilgrims and tending the Sacred Mosque equal to one who believes in Allah and the Last Day and strives in His cause? They are not equal before Allah.”
Qur'an 9:19
“He set out for ḥajj, met a family eating carrion from hunger, gave them his provision and went home, saying this was better than his ḥajj that year.”
ʿAbdullāh ibn al-Mubārak (reported)
1 of 10
How to tell
Six questions before you give your time or money
Each question is one of the principles of the fiqh of priorities. Asked in order, they show whether a good deed is in its place.
Is it a duty or a choice?
An obligation comes before a voluntary act, and a communal duty no one is carrying before both.
What does it protect?
Faith, life, mind, family or wealth from ruin is a necessity. What only eases is a need; what only adorns is a refinement.
How great is the harm?
The greater harm goes first, and averting harm comes before gaining a benefit of the same weight.
How many does it reach?
The many before the few, and what reaches others before what stays with us.
Is it certain, and will it last?
The certain before the doubtful, and the harm that cannot be undone before the one that passes.
Who else is carrying it?
If enough already do it, look for the duty that no one is carrying.
Putting it right
Where to start
The order begins at home and works outwards.
The person
Pay zakat in full first. Keep one small duty every month. Learn the order before giving.
The family
No riba, a simple nikāḥ, children steered towards the communal duties the Ummah lacks.
The masjid
Spend on its work before its walls: the poor fund, the madrasah, the clinic, legal help.
The community
Rank causes by the harm, not the coverage, and give part of every effort to the remedy, not only relief.
Get involved